Thursday, March 26, 2015

Rules are for fools... or are they?


Let's face it we all have to deal with rules, they are there in front of us every single day. Society as a whole is nothing but a ruleset governed environment. We all know we have to pay taxes, can't simply shoot someone that pisses us off and more recently regardless of fame can't verbally and physically abuse a co-worker and continue on like nothing happened.

Yes granted some rules are just plain fucking stupid, I mean why can I drive 400 miles in either direction with a truck and tailor and be allowed to drive the overall speed limit yet within the 400 miles (CA) I have a rule that means I have to watch even Prius drivers pass me by? Yea the 55mph rule in CA sucks and is stupid!

When we move into things such as major sporting events and activities things become a little looser and we replace gun toting police officers with whistle blowing referee's and subjectivity and human error comes into play. We've all watched a sport we love and seen a shitty call from the ref and how does that make you feel? For me as a Football (Soccer to you yanks!) fan it really pisses me off I know that much!

Now regardless of shitty calls and such we all can agree that the rules within professional sports are fairly clear and concise and more so we all understand them, obviously they are broken from time to time hence there are penalties and such but all the same we do know and understand them and can agree they are in place for a reason!

Now here's where things take a twist, Ability!

Ability has no bearing on the rules we are all governed with in our everyday lives, sure we all have the ability to chamber a round and shoot someone but in most incidences we receive a penalty for doing so, if we're not caught it's similar in some regards to sports as we could say that person cheated the law or rules case in point would be OJ.

But in sports ability has a much more pronounced meaning, let's face it we all dreamed as kids for running out with XYZ shirt/jersey on at favored teams stadium playing for them professionally but the reality is the statistic for having the ability to be professional athlete is in the 0.001%.

Now as we're all (well for the most part) not in that 0.001% does that mean we can't play? Hell no we all fall into different levels of Ability and such as which there are different levels to play in much the same as Time Attack (yes you did have to read through all of the above shit to finally get to any form of point I may be making!)

So if we're drawing comparison from Societies rules, Sports and using Ability (Ability in some cases with regards to Time Attack can also be offset by cash flow, see below) as our cross reference we have something that breaks down a little like this,

Overall Governing Body Sanctioning rules = Society's rules

The are the general sports rules and guidelines which cover the specifics of the sport and guidelines to be followed by all participating.

Unlimited Class specific rules = Professional athlete

These are if you like your 0.001% with the exception they don't get millions and get to go home and bang Victoria Beckham. Love them or hate them they are the ones that people pay to watch and for the most part have the if you like most Ability!

Modified Class specific rules = Semi Pro athlete

I can't fully determine the statistic here but let's as a broad example call it 25%, these are your guys either apprenticing with the aim of being in the 0.001% Ability stakes above or simply this is where they are going to stay as their Ability which for the most part is cash dependent dictates this is the highest level they will achieve. This level still draws at times a paying sizable crowd without the players bringing in the millions and banging the superstar wifes!

Street Class specific rules = Saturday/Sunday league players

This statistic is huge in sports, Time Attack has one additional class to make reference too but it is equally the largest of the classes so for arguments sake we'll call it 50%. These guys are you're bread and butter, they play week in week out and without them your sport falls out of the mainstream, think of it like this if these guys that give up all their spare time and earnings to play and didn't go to games and buy the teams apparel and such there really would be no sport or need for the guys with more Ability/Cash. Or at the very least the sport as a whole falls out of the mainstream and simply becomes a niche thing sustained by a small amount of die hard's grasping to what was or could have been (Oh the irony of how this hits the mark with current US Time Attack huh?)

Enthusiast Class specific rules = Hmm I've seen that dude bend the ball and bang the hot chick I need to see what this is all about

We'll call these guys the remaining 24.999%, the way I see them rightly or wrongly is these are the guys that perhaps played another sport at much different Ability level and are checking out something new, perhaps the flipped the channel and thought oh that looks cool I'd be down to give that a try.

And the Point is?

Now I'm sure at this point your saying OK Mike you just spent some time (and/or wasted mine reading this) and yet there is really no clearly defined point other than we all can agree we'd like to be that Jeff Westphal lookalike that's made millions from kicking a ball around and gets to bang a smoking hot superstar wife!

Well here's the thing as I see it, Time Attack at least in the United States is at crossroads. Sure I think the last couple of years it's made a very small dent in the damage that occurred in the past but still falls into the niche category supported only by the current crop of die hard's. The crossroads I speak of are whether it's to push on and make it's way back into the mainstream or slowly dwindle as the die hard's move on.

Everybody has their own opinion and obviously I am no different so my opinion of where it's at now and how it takes the right road from this point goes a little something like this,

The rules we're working with are to put it simple archaic written in something like 2004 and slightly tweaked since then, this has lead to a ruleset which has no clearly defined path between whether it's written from the stance of if it says you can anything it doesn't state you can't or visa versa. Keep in mind that the clear determining factor the rules were originally written around were tires being the main differentiating factor between classes, this worked in 2004 and too some extent till not all that long ago but started to fail badly as the sport reached it's peak due to some of these reasons,

 The sport grew and thus tire manufactures support and willingness to create specific tires occurred which in some cases completely lays to waste the existing treadwear class rules.

Technology, obviously nothing stands still modifications that were simply not present at the inception of the rules are not governed

Participation increase and lack of rules that were in place being enforced (think of RTA hay day and all the waivers)


Now if you're thinking OK but how and why are the rules so important for the continued growth of the sport? It's simple, even if my above statistics are mere fiction they at least are somewhat in the ball park. So if your sports main growth stream is its Saturday/Sunday league players (Street class) then without clearly defined rules which set apart it's differences with the higher ability/classes meaning players/cars with higher ability or cash can just run in their class collecting trophies why would more and more people join it's ranks?

At the end of the day most people go out there for fun but at a certain point as in the case with getting hammered by other teams at a sport each week it losses it's appeal and the participant level dwindles. There's a very good reason for the lower classes as they are for everyone to go out there have fun and perhaps if their lucky get up on the podium once in a while and get soaked with champagne, if obvious gulfs in ability/cash or the like exist this becomes an impossible reality which only hurts the overall sport.

My take on how things are shaping up currently due to if you like the loop holes or lack of adapting the rules to the current technology and available modifications is that you end up with you're primary attendance class being overran with trailer queened purpose built race cars running on fictional treadwear tires which serves to not only reduce your overall event attendance but also skew the goals of the class participants (think non achievable records and such) but don't worry they still have some interior so they ain't race cars right?


These are my views and opinions only so feel free to disregard/ignore or call me a wanker it really won't hurt my feelings at all I just felt compelled to explain my own thoughts based on the fact I really would like to see the sport grow as I think it can in the US and nothing more than that.

1 comment:

  1. Rules and Time Attack are an interesting subject. Sometimes it's hard for people to look past themselves and understand what will be best for the sport. There is the thought of making classes accessible for more people (trying to control costs to a degree), figuring out controlling factors such as tires, power, weight. You could also use rules from WTAC to unify rules from the main event to the lower levels but does that suit TA here in the US? Personally I thing with each season the top tier teams should be evaluated and rules made based on what they used to win. I think tech should be vastly more enforced but I also understand from the organization standpoint it has costs but I think those costs could be worth it for the orgs in the overall.

    ReplyDelete